EPA Dismisses Science on Pesticide Chlorpyrifos Citing Lack Of “Raw Data”

Grapes sprayed with pesticides     Photo: Wikimedia Commons

By Monica Medina and Rozi Beresin-Scher, ODP Contributing Writer

The Trump Administration announced last week that it has rejected the settled scientific evidence linking the pesticide chlorpyrifos to serious health problems, particularly in children. This pesticide, which is widely used on soybeans, almonds, grapes, and other crops, has been proven to harm children’s neurological development. The agency now claims that the science on the subject “remains unresolved,” which directly contradicts the agency’s own conclusions from just 5 years ago. In 2017, the Trump administration reversed Barack Obama’s 2015 pledge to ban chlorpyrifos. Now, the EPA is arguing that the scientific research itself is inconclusive by excluding several perfectly conclusive studies by citing “lack of access to raw data,” according to The New York Times.

Why this matters: Under the false flag of transparency, EPA is putting children at greater risk.  The agency is now disregarding the science it previously relied upon apparently due to a proposed new rule allowing it to disregard studies where the patients’ identities and medical records are kept anonymous, a common practice in clinical research. As the New York Times put it when the “transparency” rule was first proposed, “[this] regulation would let the federal government dismiss or downplay some of the most important environmental research of the past decades.”  It looks like that is exactly what EPA just did — despite the potential harm to children and farm workers.  

Deadly Consequences

In 2018, the agrochemical trade group CropLife petitioned the EPA to halt any regulatory decisions that are heavily influenced by epidemiological data. According to the New York Times, this strategy mirrors efforts once made by tobacco companies to undermine research on the dangers of smoking. The rule entitled “Strengthening Transparency in Regulatory Science,” which epidemiologist David Michaels describes as “weaponized transparency,” requires regulators to privilege scientific studies where the data is publicly released. Because epidemiological studies track participants’ health, their raw data often includes confidential medical records. 

Fetal exposure to chlorpyrifos has been linked to lower birth weight, learning disabilities, and loss of working memory for toddlers.  As Earthjustice explained in its statement reacting to the EPA’s decision, “chlorpyrifos is just one of dozens of organophosphates (OP) pesticides linked with damage to the developing brains of children. A growing body of evidence shows that prenatal exposure to very low levels of chlorpyrifos — levels far lower than what EPA used to set regulatory limits — harms babies permanently. Studies show that exposure to chlorpyrifos, and other OP pesticides during pregnancy, is associated with lower birth weight, attention deficit disorders, autism spectrum disorder, reduced IQ, and loss of working memory.”  Earthjustice sued the agency on behalf of dozens of farmworkers and health groups at the time when it first withdrew the Obama rule and won. In July of 2019 even when ordered to do so by the court, EPA refused to ban chlorpyrifos from food, a decision which Earthjustice again challenged in a case that is still pending.

Up Next

Update: Joshua Tree Petition Granted For One Year While Officials Conduct Study

Update: Joshua Tree Petition Granted For One Year While Officials Conduct Study

by Amy Lupica, ODP Contributing Writer On Tuesday, the California Fish and Game Commission voted to accept a petition that will grant the Joshua tree, the famous twisty-limbed yucca plant native to the Mojave desert, endangered species status for one year while the state conducts a study. The plant is now considered a “candidate species” […]

Continue Reading 658 words
Wildfire Smoke Increases COVID-19 Risk for Frontline Communities

Wildfire Smoke Increases COVID-19 Risk for Frontline Communities

by Razi Beresin-Scher and Miro Korenha According to recent reporting from The Hill, atmospheric smoke is exacerbating the toll of the COVID-19 virus in Oregon and California. Smoke inhalation weakens the immune systems of those suffering from asthma and other underlying respiratory conditions, compromising their ability to recover from the virus.  Researchers at the Harvard […]

Continue Reading 584 words
Study Estimates Number of AC Units Needed Will Triple in Next Thirty Years

Study Estimates Number of AC Units Needed Will Triple in Next Thirty Years

Increasing populations, incomes, urbanization, and temperatures could “triple the number of AC units installed worldwide by midcentury, pushing the total toward 6 billion,” as James Temple reported for the MIT Technology Review. This could create one of the “largest sources of rising electricity demand around the world.”

Why This Matters: This is the paradox of climate change. As the world warms, cooling will be even more necessary.

Continue Reading 528 words

Want the planet in your inbox?

Subscribe to the email that top lawmakers, renowned scientists, and thousands of concerned citizens turn to each morning for the latest environmental news and analysis.