A Major Victory for Indigenous Rights Against the Dakota Access Pipeline

Photo: Voice of America

By Zoey Shipley

A federal judge on Wednesday said the cursory environmental review for the Dakota Access Pipeline was fatally flawed and ruled that the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers has to conduct a full environmental impact assessment – the court is still considering whether to halt operations in the interim. The ruling goes to the heart of a decision to permit the pipeline to cross under the Missouri River after they concluded that there “would be no significant environmental impact,” a decision challenged by the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe who sued the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers.

Why This Matters: The 1,000 mile Dakota Access Pipeline “carries crude oil from North Dakota to Illinois” with “nearly 500,000 barrels of oil” being transported each day through the pipeline. This creates a great risk for the Standing Rock’s Tribe that is located directly downstream of the river and depends on this source of water for living. The tribe uses the Missouri River for “fishing, drinking, and religious ceremonies” and a leak from the pipeline would be disastrous for the Souix nation and surrounding areas.  The judge held that the government had not done enough to study the risks of a major spill or whether the pipeline’s leak detection system was adequate.

The Fight Continues

Though this was a major victory for indigenous nations, environmentalists, and other citizens affected by the pipeline; the fight is not over. The judge “did not rule on whether oil could continue to flow through” the pipeline. If the pipeline continues, it still leaves a major threat to the Sioux nation as the court battles continue. The pipeline already has a history of leaking, in 2019 the line leaked “about 383,000 gallons of oil, which could fill more than half of an Olympic-sized swimming pool.”

It may not have been an official end to the pipeline, but this decision will help the Sioux Tribe in their fight to have their rights recognized. “After years of commitment to defending our water and earth, we welcome this news of a significant legal win,” stated Standing Rock Sioux Tribe Chairman Mike Faith about the decision. “It’s humbling to see how actions we took four years ago to defend our ancestral homeland continue to inspire national conversations about how our choices ultimately affect this planet. Perhaps in the wake of this court ruling the federal government will begin to catch on, too, starting by actually listening to us when we voice our concerns.”

To Go Deeper: Read this Mother Jones story on the history of the #NoDAPL movement.  And you can read the court’s decision here.

Illustration: Starship Earth: The Big Picture

Up Next

One-Third of Topsoil Is Gone From Midwestern Farmland

One-Third of Topsoil Is Gone From Midwestern Farmland

New research shows that fertile, carbon-rich topsoil is completely gone from one-third of all farmland in the Midwest, severely impairing crop growth and future harvests. 

Why This Matters: Experts say this “growing” problem is mostly due to over-tilling the soil and other unsustainable farming practices.

Continue Reading 523 words
Melting Permafrost, Exploding Methane Behind Mystery Craters in Russian Arctic

Melting Permafrost, Exploding Methane Behind Mystery Craters in Russian Arctic

by Amy Lupica, ODP Staff Writer A new study may reveal the mystery behind violently exploding craters in the Siberian tundra. Last year, a 17th massive permafrost crater cracked open in the Russian arctic; the first was spotted in 2013, leaving scientists searching for a reason as to why it had appeared.  The craters, the most recent 100 […]

Continue Reading 624 words
The World’s Cities Are Sinking

The World’s Cities Are Sinking

by Ashira Morris, ODP Staff Writer How much does a city weigh? You can’t put San Francisco on a scale, but new research from the US Geological Service estimates that the number is 1.6 trillion kilograms, about the same as 250,000,000 elephants.  This isn’t just a clever math problem, though: all that weight is causing […]

Continue Reading 460 words

Want the planet in your inbox?

Subscribe to the email that top lawmakers, renowned scientists, and thousands of concerned citizens turn to each morning for the latest environmental news and analysis.