Cable News Won’t Talk Climate During Super Tuesday Coverage, Here’s What They’re Missing

A satellite image, August 6, 2018, shows smoke from multiple large California wildfires. Image: NASA

Super Tuesday is just a day away and there’s been a glaring omission from the pundit analysis happening on cable news: how climate change will shape the vote in California, the looming prize that will help (barring an unforeseen circumstance) either Joe Biden or Bernie Sanders clinch the Democratic nomination. While several polls have shown that Democratic voters overall are increasingly worried about climate change, in California the state of the planet truly is a key voting priority. In a state where wildfires are exacerbating already high levels of housing insecurity, fire-season blackouts are putting into question the future of investor-owned utilities, and where drought is threatening the world’s 5th largest economy, how candidates talk about climate action is shaping important political endorsements and the calculations voters are making before heading to the polls.

So since cable news won’t air a segment about climate change in the California primary, this is how we’d produce the segment to compare the ways in which leading Democrats Bernie Sanders, Michael Bloomberg, and Joe Biden’s climate plans stack up in the Golden State: 

Housing: The three top issues for California voters are homelessness, housing affordability, and the environment. And in California, all three of these issues are intrinsically linked. Wildfires are increasing in severity in California and each year, more housing is destroyed in a state where affordable housing is already in a crisis situation. Bernie Sanders, most boldly of all the candidates, has proposed to expand the National Housing Trust Fund in order to build the units necessary to guarantee housing as a right to all Americans. Meanwhile, Joe Biden vows to fight housing shortages through the same mechanisms that he’d use to combat urban sprawl–mainly linking dense housing to public transportation. Both Biden and Bloomberg have similar aspirations in subsidizing rent, building more affordable housing units and helping renters transition to homeownership. However, unlike Bloomberg, Biden has vowed to support California Rep. Maxine Waters’  $13 billion Ending Homelessness Act.

PG&E: After California’s largest utility was found liable of sparking the lethal Camp Fire and also declared bankruptcy, PG&E’s preemptive blackouts have cost the state billions in lost revenue as well as overwhelming inconvenience to hundreds of thousands of Californians. PG&E’s woes have fueled a conversation about whether the state should take over its utilities and the need for California to fast-track distributed energy resources so that energy transmission lines aren’t needed.

Bernie Sanders has come out swinging for PG&E, naming the greed of its executives as the reason for the mismanagement and chaos as well as reiterating the need to have the state take over the utility. As a result, PG&E’s largest union has taken aim at Sanders, saying that his endorsement of a public takeover would be prohibitively expensive and misguided.

And while Biden’s wildfire mitigation plan isn’t as robust or detailed as Sanders’, California’s largest firefighter union endorsed Biden after the support he showed them in the wake of the deadly 2018 Camp Fire. Though it’s still unclear how much these unions will affect that way in which Californians vote, Joe Biden is more aligned with the specific California labor groups most affected by wildfires.

The type of future investor-owned utilities face in California will be an important development for the rest of the nation to watch. After all, if California’s utilities aren’t able to provide steady, reliable energy, then how can the state maintain its status as the world’s 5th largest economy?

Drought: In the new century, California has had to grapple with an intensifying drought that’s threatening not just the state’s agricultural sector, but is forcing cities to grapple with water rationing and more stringent water management practices. Though there have been years where atmospheric rivers have brought floods, much of California is back to drought conditions. A federal plan to help manage water will be key, especially with looming Colorado River water shortages threatening the lifeline of cities like Los Angeles.

While Joe Biden identifies the water problems the West is facing, neither his plan nor that of his closest Democratic competitors have a clear outline of how to grapple with uncertain water resources for a state of 40 million people. At the same time, they haven’t been pressed by the media to clarify how they would handle this threat. If Cape Town running out of water was any indication of how dire circumstances can become, candidates need to be prepared to address a water crisis in America’s second-largest city.

Why This Matters: The adage goes that the future happens first in California. When it comes to preparing for climate change and a green energy future, that’s certainly the case as California is a prime example that comprehensive strides to limit GHG emissions do not have to harm the economy:

Graphic: PPIC

California voters are climate voters and economic issues in California are fundamentally climate issues. When Californians cast their votes tomorrow, they will in large part be choosing the candidate whose climate plan is best suited to limiting emissions while preparing the nation for a future where we’ll be feeling the effects of a rapidly warming planet. Whether it’s Sanders, Biden, or Bloomberg, the winner of California’s primary will set the tone for how climate issues are talked about throughout the 2020 presidential election. That’s why any Super Tuesday coverage that doesn’t cover climate change as a top issue in California is missing a key part of the factors motivating the state’s electorate.

Up Next

Congressional Democrats & Biden Administration Move Towards Passing Largest Climate Investment in US History

Congressional Democrats & Biden Administration Move Towards Passing Largest Climate Investment in US History

By Ashira Morris, ODP Staff Writer Late last week, President Biden and a critical mass of Democrats in the Senate and House agreed on the details of Build Back Better legislation — a $1.85 trillion overall investment that includes a record-setting  $555 billion dollars to take on the climate crisis.    The agreement marked a […]

Continue Reading 502 words
Big Oil Testifies in Congress about Decades of Disinformation

Big Oil Testifies in Congress about Decades of Disinformation

By Amy Lupica, ODP Daily Editor Top executives from Big Oil companies ExxonMobil, BP, Chevron, and Shell testified before Congress yesterday amid accusations and revelations about their industry’s efforts to mislead the public about human-caused climate change while claiming to be in favor of climate action. A report released Thursday morning by the House Committee […]

Continue Reading 542 words
UN Says Climate Pledges Are Too Weak to Stop Warming

UN Says Climate Pledges Are Too Weak to Stop Warming

By Natasha Lasky, ODP Staff Writer As the world gets ready for COP26 in Glasgow next week, many nations are upping their pledges to lower emissions before 2030. But according to a UN report released Tuesday, even if Argentina, Britain, Canada, the EU, South Africa, and the US achieve their pledged goals, it would account […]

Continue Reading 326 words

Want the planet in your inbox?

Subscribe to the email that top lawmakers, renowned scientists, and thousands of concerned citizens turn to each morning for the latest environmental news and analysis.