Climate Change Threatens the 30-Year Mortgage

Steve Helber/AP

CBS News reported last fall that climate change could punch a hole through the financial system by making 30-year home mortgages — the lifeblood of the American housing market — effectively unobtainable in entire regions across parts of the U.S.

Recent reporting from the New York Times goes further to explain that homebuyers are increasingly using mortgages that make it easier for them to stop making their monthly payments and walk away from the loan if the home floods or becomes unsellable or unlivable.

  • More banks are getting buyers in coastal areas to make bigger down payments — often as much as 40%.
  • Banks are also getting these mortgages off their own books by selling them to government-backed buyers like Fannie Mae, where taxpayers would be on the hook financially if any of the loans fail.

Why This Matters: The housing market doesn’t adequately account for the risks of climate change. For instance, mortgage lenders, portfolio managers and buyers of mortgages don’t take into account climate-induced floods, except to determine if a house sits in a 100-year floodplain at the time the mortgage is issued. But once that risk is reflected, mortgages may become much more difficult for Americans to attain.

Banks are moving quickly to transfer mortgages with flood risks off their books. As the New York Times explained, tellingly, the lenders selling off coastal mortgages the fastest are smaller local banks, which are more likely than large national banks to know which neighborhoods face the greatest climate risk. It’s because these small banks are more aware of localized climate change risks.

The Future: Michael Berman, a former official with the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development and former chairman of the Mortgage Bankers Association told CBS that he predicts lenders could “blue-line” entire regions where flood risks are high — a reference to redlining, the practice of refusing mortgages to minorities. 

Additionally, in 30 years from now, if global-warming emissions follow their current trajectory, almost half a million existing homes will be on land that floods at least once a year.

The Flood Insurance Problem: Politico wrote earlier this year that in order to reduce risk, the mortgage companies rely on another government enterprise, the National Flood Insurance Program, to cover the cost of flood damage to homes with Fannie and Freddie mortgages. But the flood insurance program itself is insolvent after years of paying out more than it collects. When Congress tried to fix the program in 2012, it was forced to backtrack after flood insurance premiums billed to homeowners spiked.

  • Between 2006 and 2018, nearly 600,000 houses were built in 100-year floodplains, bringing the total to 4.1 million homes. In that same time period, 300,000 mortgages were added to homes in floodplains, bringing the total number of loans to 7 million.
  • As residential construction and lending have risen in tandem, they’ve outpaced insurance. The number of taxpayer-backed flood insurance policies in effect nationwide peaked in 2006 at 5.5 million after Hurricane Katrina. But by 2018, there were only 5.2 million policies in effect.

Up Next

US Climate Negotiator Back For More: Sue Biniaz

US Climate Negotiator Back For More: Sue Biniaz

As Former Secretary of State John Kerry looked to assemble an all-star team to support him in his new Climate Special Envoy role, there was one person he wanted by his side — Sue Biniaz.  The Former Deputy Legal Adviser at the State Department, who left the agency after the Trump administration took office, knows the Paris Agreement inside and out.

Continue Reading 294 words
Direct Air Capture is Ready for its Close-up

Direct Air Capture is Ready for its Close-up

By Dr. Julio Friedmann As Congress prepares major climate legislation and President Biden looks to take more executive action, net-zero emissions has become the science-based star of the show. That show features a climate solution that is often overlooked – undiscovered and waiting in the wings. Carbon dioxide removal (CDR), which pulls carbon dioxide (CO2) […]

Continue Reading 1065 words
New UN Report Says It’s Crunch Time to Reach Climate Goals

New UN Report Says It’s Crunch Time to Reach Climate Goals

by Amy Lupica, ODP Staff Writer UN Climate Change has published the Initial NDC Synthesis Report, which evaluated information from 75 parties to the Paris agreement representing 30% of global greenhouse gas emissions.  The results: “governments are nowhere close to the level of ambition needed to limit climate change to 1.5 degrees and meet the […]

Continue Reading 531 words

Want the planet in your inbox?

Subscribe to the email that top lawmakers, renowned scientists, and thousands of concerned citizens turn to each morning for the latest environmental news and analysis.