Coney Barrett’s Climate Controversy

Judge Coney Barrett Swearing-In        Photo: VWEAA, Wikimedia CC

President Trump’s Supreme Court nominee, Judge Amy Coney Barrett, created a bit of controversy during her nomination hearing before the Senate Judiciary Committee last week when she called climate change itself “controversial.”  When asked by Senator and Democratic VP Nominee Kamala Harris about whether climate change is happening and threatening our air and water, Barrett replied that she could not answer the question because it is politically controversial.  She also said, in response to a question from Republican Senator John Kennedy of Louisiana, said she is not a scientist and could not opine on whether the planet is warming.

Why This Matters:  On a series of climate change questions from various Senators, Judge Barrett’s unwillingness to discuss the topic seemed less than candid.  She argued, “I do not think my “views on global warming or climate change are relevant to the job I would do as a judge, nor do I feel like I have views that are informed enough, and I haven’t studied scientific data.”  What?  Yes, they do.

What Coney Barrett Said to Senator Harris

As reported by The Times, the exchange went like this:

“Do you believe that climate change is happening and threatening the air we breathe and the water that we drink?” Ms. Harris asked.

Judge Barrett responded, “You asked me uncontroversial questions, like Covid-19 being infectious or if smoking causes cancer” to solicit “an opinion from me on a very contentious matter of public debate,” climate change.

“I will not do that,” Judge Barrett concluded. “I will not express a view on a matter of public policy, especially one that is politically controversial.”

Greta’s Response

Greta Thunberg took issue with Coney Barrett’s response by tweeting “To be fair, I don’t have any ‘views on climate change’ either. Just like I don’t have any ‘views’ on gravity, the fact that the earth is round, photosynthesis nor evolution.”

Other Experts 

“She’s a smart and sophisticated person,” Richard L. Revesz, director of the institute for policy integrity at New York University Law School told The Times. “If she didn’t want to associate herself with the climate denial perspective, she could have used different words.”

The Times noted that climate change is not really especially controversial with Americans today:  “73 percent of Americans say that global warming is happening, and 62 percent of Americans accept that it is human caused.”

Up Next

First African American Catholic Cardinal Supports the Fight Against Climate Change

First African American Catholic Cardinal Supports the Fight Against Climate Change

Wilton Gregory, appointed the first African American Catholic cardinal, is an ally in the fight against global warming. He not only believes in climate change, but he also has supported the Pope’s landmark environmental treatise— “Laudato Si:’ On Care for our Common Home” —when many archbishops in the United States did not, and put together a plan to address the Pope’s concerns about climate change that has been an inspiration for other faith leaders in Boston, Columbus, Minneapolis, San Diego, and other cities.

Why this Matters:  Spiritual leaders across faiths have been taking a stand against climate change. On November 16th, 47 faith institutions— 42 representing Catholics— announced their divestment from fossil fuels.

Continue Reading 505 words

Interview of the Week: Adam Kolton of the Alaska Wilderness League

This week, just in time for Thanksgiving, we talk with Adam Kolton, the Executive Director of the Alaska Wilderness League about the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge, Arctic Indigenous Communities, and conserving Alaskan wilderness.  Watch the entire interview.  Here are a few highlights: On the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge: “This is the area where hundreds of […]

Continue Reading 245 words

Interview of the Week: Indonesian Minister Luhut Binsar Pandjaitan

This week we had the pleasure of sitting with Luhut Binsar Pandjaitan, Indonesia’s Coordinating Minister for Maritime Affairs and Investment, a title he’s held since October 2019. We asked the minister about how Indonesia is balancing the precarious equation of conserving its rich biodiversity while addressing the duel climate and COVID crises.   Now that […]

Continue Reading 112 words

Want the planet in your inbox?

Subscribe to the email that top lawmakers, renowned scientists, and thousands of concerned citizens turn to each morning for the latest environmental news and analysis.