Court Orders Shell to Reduce Emissions in First-of-its-Kind Legal Victory

By Amy Lupica, ODP Staff Writer

A Dutch court has ordered Royal Dutch Shell to slash its CO2 emissions by 45% by 2030, including those from both its operations and the energy products it sells. This is the first time a court has ordered a company to reduce its emissions to achieve climate goals. Experts say the ruling could have broad-reaching impacts for similar cases worldwide and that the industry may see similar mandates in other countries and courts in the future.  Advocates are celebrating this move toward legal accountability for big fossil fuel companies.

Why This Matters: Despite many oil companies making promises to cut emissions, the world isn’t moving fast enough to meet the goals of the Paris agreement. Shell previously pledged to meet net-zero emissions, but experts and environmental groups say they aren’t taking their pledges seriously. Shell has continued to make investments in oil and gas extraction. This isn’t surprising; oil and gas companies have led the world to the tipping point, pushing anti-climate action agendas and fighting tooth and nail to protect their financial interests. The Dutch court that issued the order said that holding these companies accountable is key to meeting climate goals and upholding human rights across the globe.

Raging Bull

Shell has announced that it intends to fight the ruling and that its current climate goals align with international destinations. “We are investing billions of dollars in low-carbon energy, including electric vehicle charging, hydrogen, renewables, and biofuels. We want to grow demand for these products and scale up our new energy businesses even more quickly. We will continue to focus on these efforts and fully expect to appeal today’s disappointing court decision,” the company said in a statement. Shell has currently pledged to reduce its emissions by 20% by 2030 and 45% by 2035. Even if the company appeals, the verdict is immediately enforceable, though critics say that may be more easily said than done. The order will most likely only be enforceable in the Netherlands, and the court found that Shell’s current carbon emissions were, in fact, lawful.

Despite potential complications, advocates are celebrating. “This is a turning point in history,” said Roger Cox, a lawyer for Friends of the Earth Netherlands. Others are looking forward to what the future may hold for similar litigation. “I can imagine this will inspire a series of other cases against companies, especially those active in the oil extraction industries like Shell,” said Eric De Brabandere, a professor at Leiden University. “It is a groundbreaking decision, it’s really a landmark.”

Cherry on Top

Even without litigation, Shell isn’t the only corporation facing emissions chopping blocks. Activist investors are seeking to replace almost a third of ExxonMobil’s board to push the company to implement climate action more quickly. On Wednesday, Chevron’s shareholders are expected to vote on new emissions targets. Advocates say a wave of change is right on the horizon. “Shell is the first but will not be the last company that will be forced to stop dangerous climate change,” Friends of the Earth Netherlands director Donald Pols told reporters. “As of today, climate lawsuits are a material risk for all major polluters in the world,” he added.

Up Next

One Climate Thing: Get It Together G7

One Climate Thing: Get It Together G7

There were certainly some positive climate commitments that came from the gathering of G7 leaders last week. Yet many experts and activists feel as if the richest nations in the world have room to be more ambitious and must lead the world in decarbonization. British environmentalist Sir David Attenborough had nothing but straight talk for […]

Continue Reading 140 words
G7 Countries Promise to Stop Financing Coal — Don’t Set Date to Stop Burning It

G7 Countries Promise to Stop Financing Coal — Don’t Set Date to Stop Burning It

by Ashira Morris, ODP Staff Writer World leaders from the Group of 7 countries wrapped up their first post-pandemic in-person summit on Sunday, and the climate crisis was one of the primary agenda items. The heads of state from the U.S., U.K., France, Germany, Canada, Italy, and Japan (as well as the European Union) Agreed […]

Continue Reading 408 words
“Megadrought” Takes Lake Mead to an All-Time Low

“Megadrought” Takes Lake Mead to an All-Time Low

The nation’s largest reservoir, Lake Mead, created by the Hoover Dam on the Colorado River, has reached record lows (at only 36% full) in the face of a severe drought sweeping the western U.S. The reservoir supplies drinking water for 25 million people in Los Angeles, San Diego, Phoenix, Tucson, Las Vegas, and more.

Why This Matters: Drought is becoming a permanent fixture across the west, and dry conditions are moving further east each year. 

Continue Reading 588 words

Want the planet in your inbox?

Subscribe to the email that top lawmakers, renowned scientists, and thousands of concerned citizens turn to each morning for the latest environmental news and analysis.