Federal Environmental Enforcement Is Back, While Trump Hotel Violates IL State Laws

Trump Hotel Chicago    Photo: Tony the Tiger, Wiki CC

The Justice Department’s Environmental lawyers last week reversed numerous Trump administration policies, including one that allows companies to do environmental restoration and remediation projects as part of their fines and penalties.  The Department also reversed a Trump policy that had prevented the department from pursuing civil enforcement and penalties in cases where states had already prosecuted violations of state environmental laws.

  • In all, DOJ overturned nine Trump administration policies that had loosened environmental law enforcement because those policies were “inconsistent with longstanding Division policy and practice” and “may impede the full exercise of enforcement discretion in the Division’s cases.”

At the same time, a state court in Illinois held the Trump International Hotel in Chicago had violated state environmental laws because it was using river water without a valid permit.

Why This Matters:  Our environmental laws are only effective if there is a credible threat of enforcement to ensure compliance, and when it is clear that no one — even a former-President — is above the law.  The policy reversals came from career lawyers at the DOJ and were not politically motivated.  Indeed, Biden Attorney General nominee Merrick Garland has not yet been confirmed — these moves are a return to long-established “norms.”

Supplemental Projects Make For Effective Enforcement

The DOJ for decades – through Republican and Democratic administrations — had effectively used “supplemental environmental projects” or SEPs — because they were a way of rectifying the harms caused by environmental violations.  Both environmental prosecutors and companies who violated the law liked to engage in actions like cleaning up streams or toxic chemicals from dumping sites as a way of making restitution with impacted communities.  The DOJ allowed companies to offset fines with up to eighty percent of what a company spent on such projects.

Trump Hotel Violations 

The Trump Hotel case had been pending in Chicago since 2018 when the company’s permit lapsed but the hotel continued to suck in more than 19 million gallons of Chicago River water per day for cooling and then returned the water at a higher temperature, The Washington Post reported.  The judge has not set the penalty in the case yet, but the city was seeking $50,000 for the violations plus $10,000 every day starting at the onset of the violation until the issue is fixed.  Former President Trump decried the action through his lawyers, who alleged the enforcement case was politically motivated.

Up Next

Interview of the Week: Mike Stanton

The Biden administration is hoping to move the United States into the electric vehicle era through massive investments in incentives to get EVs on the road as well as the build-out of 500,000 EV charging stations across the country. Yet this revolution is reliant upon Americans making the switch to EVs in mass numbers. As […]

Continue Reading 241 words

Achieving Transportation Equity Can Start Now

Recently, Transportation for America’s Director Beth Osborne sat down to speak with former Transportation Secretary Anthony Foxx (now, Chief Policy Officer at Lyft) about how a massive investment in infrastructure can address inequality and provide innovative transportation solutions for a multitude of communities. From micro mobility, to reassessing freeways, and the expansion of public transit, […]

Continue Reading 485 words

Interview of the Week: Congressman Ted Lieu (D-CA)

This week we sat down with Congressman Ted Lieu who represents California’s 33rd Congressional district. His district also happens to be one of the most climate-vulnerable regions in the nation where wildfires, extreme heat, and sea-level rise are creating conditions that necessitate comprehensive climate action from the federal government. More specifically, the Congressman told us […]

Continue Reading 213 words

Want the planet in your inbox?

Subscribe to the email that top lawmakers, renowned scientists, and thousands of concerned citizens turn to each morning for the latest environmental news and analysis.