Fighting Deforestation and Poverty Go Hand In Hand In Indonesia

Deforestation in Berau, Kalimantan, Indonesia     Photo: Mahastra Wibisono, Newsweek

A new study published yesterday in the journal Science Advances found that in Indonesia, a country with bountiful but highly exploited natural resources, a national anti-poverty program also reduced deforestation as a side benefit. The program uses conditional cash transfers (CCTs) to elevate families over the poverty line, an increasingly popular way to provide assistance, conditional on taking specific actions related to education and health.  As a result, families did not need to resort to clearing forests to make ends meet or grow more food during difficult times.  The researchers compared satellite images of areas where the government made CCTs to those where they did not and found a distinct increase in forest cover in those with cash assistance.

Why This Matters: Indonesia is one of the poorest nations in the world, and has the third-largest amount of tropical rain forest.  It also, according to Global Forest Watch, is the country with the third-highest rate of rainforest loss in the world in 2019. Due to this loss, Indonesia is also the fifth-largest emitter of greenhouse gasses in the world, according to the World Resources Institute. A program that curbs deforestation and cuts greenhouse gas emissions in Indonesia while reducing poverty seems like a no-brainer. 

Big Benefits, Small Dollars

When compared to the costs of climate change, the Indonesia program’s benefit of keeping Indonesian rain forests intact more than justifies it.  One of the study authors argued in Science News that the economic benefits of saving the forests “justify the intervention.”  It also demonstrates that a healthy environment and strong economy are not at odds with one another — it is possible to have both.  One of the authors told Newsweek, “For decades, people have been debating whether alleviating poverty and protecting the environment are at odds with each other. Resolving this debate is important because lots of poor people are found in the same areas where we find the most endangered ecosystems, like the rainforest.”

Accidental Impact

Most interesting is the fact that the environmental benefits of reducing forest loss were not the objective of the program.  “We found that modest, but persistent, transfers of cash to extremely poor households reduced deforestation by about 30 percent. That result is surprising given that the cash transfers were not contingent on reducing deforestation and there were “many possible economic paths through which the cash might have had deleterious effects on the forests,” one author explained.  Instead, the goals were increasing education and health — that is what the CCTs were incentivizing.  The question is whether this type of cash transfer in other poor countries could have the same effect.  There are 16 tropical countries that currently have some form of anti-poverty cash payment program.  The authors believe that CCTs in other Asian countries may have the same impact.

Up Next

Deforestation Claims 160k Square Miles from 2004-17, WWF Report Reveals

Deforestation Claims 160k Square Miles from 2004-17, WWF Report Reveals

Humans need forests for our survival, from the air we breathe to the wood we use. These ecosystems also provide livelihoods for people, offer watershed protection, prevent soil erosion, and mitigate climate change. Unfortunately, a new report from World Wildlife Fund (WWF) titled “Deforestation Fronts: Drivers and Responses in a Changing World” reveals that more […]

Continue Reading 683 words
Bolsonaro’s Military Strategy Fails to Protect Amazon from Deforestation

Bolsonaro’s Military Strategy Fails to Protect Amazon from Deforestation

Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro’s most recent effort to reduce the destruction of the Amazon rainforest has failed, The Washington Post reports. Bolsonaro’s plan to deploy military troops and take illegal mining operations by surprise ultimately failed when miners got wind of it. 

Why This Matters: The health of the Amazon rainforest is crucial in the fight against climate change.

Continue Reading 601 words
Top Ten Stories of 2020: The World On Fire

Top Ten Stories of 2020: The World On Fire

This year will be remembered for literally turning the sky red — wildfires in California were so severe that they cast a red pall across large areas of the state — and the photos were the most vivid sign yet that climate change is not some future apocalypse, but is already upon us.

Continue Reading 519 words

Want the planet in your inbox?

Subscribe to the email that top lawmakers, renowned scientists, and thousands of concerned citizens turn to each morning for the latest environmental news and analysis.