Gender Bias in the World’s Natural History Museums

Image: NHM

A scientist at the Natural History Museum in London has discovered that while the institution boasts an incomparable natural history collection, it has significantly more male specimens than female specimens. In her study, Dr. Natalie Cooper discovered the same male skew in four other leading natural history museums around the world (American Museum of Natural History, the Field Museum, Muséum National d’Histoire Naturelle, the Smithsonian).

“At a time of unprecedented importance for scientists to understand ecosystems and work to protect endangered animals, any research that has used these kinds of collections is likely to be inaccurate. For instance, chemicals found in specimens are analysed to learn about their migration patterns, but some species have gender-specific diets.”

More on the Study: As Dr. Cooper explained, “We found – perhaps unsurprisingly – that there was a bias towards male specimens. It is worse in birds than in mammals, with only about 40% of bird specimens being females, but around 48% female in mammals.

The Male Bias: Journalist Caroline Criado Perez explained in Scientific American that the issue is that we’re so used to seeing the male body and lifestyle as just the standard human body and the standard human way of doing things. This also extends into scientific data collection which comes at the detriment of scientific knowledge. Criado Perez noted that the male data bias might also mean that,

  • Female astronauts don’t have appropriate space suits
  • Female police officers lack properly-fitting vests
  •  Women must take ineffective medication because male bodies are studied more readily
  • And even algorithms for AI are incredibly male-biased. For example, Google’s voice recognition software, which is meant to be the best on the market, is 70 percent less likely to recognize a female voice than a male voice because it’s trained on a voice database that is heavily skewed towards male.

Why This Matters: Not only do women struggle for representation in science but biases held by male researchers can inhibit our understanding of species and ecosystems. If the goal of conservation is to preserve species and we’re only studying how the male of that species functions then we’re not getting a full understanding of how to best protect threatened animals. Breaking gender bias must begin early but we must also begin to example all the instances of default male preference in our lives and workplaces if we’re to make a difference overall.

Up Next

The VA Won’t Fund Service Dogs For PTS Therapy

The VA Won’t Fund Service Dogs For PTS Therapy

Military dogs are often homeless once they are retired from service.  And worse, the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) won’t pay for veterans with Post-Traumatic Stress (PTS) to adopt them or other dogs as service dogs. Congressman John Rutherford of Florida has introduced a bill — the Puppies Assisting Wounded Servicemembers (PAWS) Act of 2019  to provide funding to veterans diagnosed with PTS who would like to obtain a service dog.

Why This Matters: It would be a real win-win to see some of these dogs– or other dogs in need of homes — go to veterans who are suffering from PTS as an alternative or supplement to other treatments.

Continue Reading 292 words
Required Reading This Veterans Day

Required Reading This Veterans Day

Here are two pieces that we recommend you read today, one of which we’ve written and the other an op-ed in the Star Tribune calling on us to honor veterans by examining the environmental damage inflicted by the military. Michael McDonald, president of Twin Cities Veterans for Peace and Jack Nelson-Pallmeyer, emeritus professor of justice […]

Continue Reading 163 words
Interview of the Week: Sam Hodder

Interview of the Week: Sam Hodder

Sam Hodder is the president and CEO of the Save the Redwoods League. Hodder has spent his career in land conservation overseeing complex conservation programs and land transactions from the remote wilderness to the inner city. ODP: What’s the difference between a redwood and a giant sequoia? SH: Giant sequoia are the most massive trees […]

Continue Reading 963 words