Great Lakes Shoreline Erosion Made Worse by Climate Change

A sunken hundred foot walkway

A sunken walkway in Indiana Dunes National Park was built to help people with disabilities enjoy the lakeside view. Due to erosion, visitors can no longer use it. Image:Tyler Lake/WTIU

Along the Great Lakes–America’s “Third Coastline”–rising lake levels coupled with erratic weather patterns are causing alarming levels of erosion. Each year, people’s homes, as well as utility lines, are becoming dangerously close to the lake’s edge. Stronger riptides, dangerous crashing waves, and boats ramming objects hidden below the lake surface are all growing concerns for public safety officials.

As Indiana Public Radio explained, “Erosion isn’t just affecting homeowners — it could also drive tourists away. Millions visit Indiana’s lakeshore every year. In Porter County alone, they contribute more than $350 million to the local economy annually, helping to fund everything from schools to fire departments.”

Why This Matters: What makes shoreline erosion along the Great Lakes so difficult to predict is that there are several forces that contribute to the damage. Increasingly heavy rains bring more water, warming weather causes evaporation, and extreme cold air outbursts as well as disappearing winter ice barriers on the sand all put different stresses on the shoreline making it more difficult for it to recover. It’s very much uncharted territory for the over 30 million people living within the Great Lakes basin. 

A Growing Concern: Scientific American wrote last year that as recently as 2013, water levels on most of the Great Lakes were very low.

  • At that time some experts proposed that climate change, along with other human actions such as channel dredging and water diversions, would cause water levels to continue to decline.
  • This scenario spurred serious concern. People living in the Great Lakes basin depend directly on the lakes for drinking water, industrial use, commercial shipping and recreation.
  • But since 2014 the issue has been too much water, not too little. High water poses just as many challenges for the region, including shoreline erosion, property damage, displacement of families and delays in planting spring crops.

What the Experts Say: Last summer, Lake Michigan broke its high-water record of 33 years, topping at 582.18 feet on July 23, according to NOAA’s Great Lakes Environmental Research Laboratory. As E&E News wrote, “that’s 2.8 feet higher than the mean July lake level over the last century, and 6.2 feet higher than it was six years ago.”

Scientists like Richard Norton, a University of Michigan professor and expert on coastal zone management, are expecting the unexpected. He noted that,

“We don’t know what the long-term standing water level is going to be. We do believe variability is going to continue between low water and high water. And when the water comes up, it’s going to come with a vengeance.”

What Can Be Done: E&E News also explained that experts worry that current environmental laws are insufficient to address today’s challenges. In Michigan, state efforts to address coastal erosion date back to the 1970s and early 1990s. This year, Michigan Governor Gretchen Whitmer was urged to issue a state of emergency for Michigan’s shoreline erosion which would open the door to federal dollars from the Disaster Relief Fund, administered through the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA). Her proposed 2021 budget set aside $40 million to help communities dealing with “the negative impacts of Michigan’s changing climate conditions” but many wonder if this is enough to address the breadth of the challenges Michigan faces.

Up Next

NY Denies Water Permit to Build Pipeline for Gas, Wants to Build Transmission Line Instead

NY Denies Water Permit to Build Pipeline for Gas, Wants to Build Transmission Line Instead

New York state environmental regulators denied for a third time a permit for a pipeline that would transport fracked natural gas from Pennsylvania to New York City and Long Island for two reasons: water quality in the Long Island Sound and fidelity to the state’s new law that requires the New York to transition its power sector to net-zero emissions by 2040 and reduce overall greenhouse gas emissions by 85 percent from 1990 levels by 2050. 

Why This Matters:  This is how the stimulus funding from the federal government should work — it must be used to build cleaner and more efficient new infrastructure that decreases our dependence on fossil fuels.

Continue Reading 488 words
Dam Failures a Risk Across the Country Due to Climate Change

Dam Failures a Risk Across the Country Due to Climate Change

The Edenville Dam failure in Michigan causing thousands to evacuate puts a spotlight on a problem that the American Society of Civil Engineers highlighted in 2017 when it gave our country a “D” for dam safety (yep – that’s it’s grade) but this grade has not significantly improved in the last 20 years.

Why This Matters:  When we think about the security risks to our nation, we need to start counting infrastructure failure due to climate change as one of the most troubling.

Continue Reading 602 words
California Wins Battle With Trump Administration About Water and Endangered Species

California Wins Battle With Trump Administration About Water and Endangered Species

A federal court on Monday put on hold President Trump’s February order that overturned agency scientists and revised federal water supply plans in California, frustrating a political promise he made to farmers in central California to lift water restrictions for the benefit of agriculture there. 

Why This Matters:  This decision is just a temporary hold on the Trump administration’s water grab.  But the time is key for both the species at risk of extinction and for the farmers who will lose out on additional water that they would get to take out of the system for agriculture now, while there is spring runoff happening — water they can’t get back later because it is already flushed through the system.

Continue Reading 504 words