Making Plastic From Fracked Natural Gas Could Replace Coal and Steel in Ohio Valley

Cracking plant under construction near Pittsburgh     Ross Mantle, The New York Times

Here in Madrid, the Mayor of Pittsburgh, Bill Peduto, touted his city as a green Phoenix, rising from the ashes of the failed steel and coal industries, with a growing economy based on high tech and health care companies and improved air and water quality — the city is turning a corner.  But he pointed out that just up the road Royal Dutch Shell is building a giant, greenhouse gas-spewing plant that will (using a process called “ethane cracking”) make tiny plastic pellets that can be turned into items like phone cases, auto parts, and food packaging according to The New York Times — it is one of several in nearby Ohio and West Virginia that are being considered because of an excess of fracked gas and a desire to see jobs like these return to the rust belt.

Why This Matters:  The Pittsburgh plant will be allowed to emit each year 2.25 million tons of carbon dioxide, 522 tons of volatile organic compounds (VOCs), and 160 tons of particulate pollution or soot, according to local NGO the Breathe Project.  These pollutants cause numerous health problems and will likely even diminish Pittsburgh’s air quality 25 miles away.  Shell’s representatives make the point that the world needs plastic for mobile phones, wind turbines, and solar panels, which is true.  Not to mention the need for good jobs for the region.  But the question becomes why should a new plant like this one be allowed to pollute so much?  In one fell swoop, the pollution from this plant that will only employ 600 people permanently could erase the gains made from Pittsburgh’s pledge to halve its greenhouse gas emissions by 2030.

How Dirty Is the Cracking Plant?

This will be the largest ethane cracker in North America and the amount is allowed to permit is the equivalent of about 480,000 cars, though Shell says the plant is likely to emit less than that.  According to the Breathe Project, which has run the numbers, the planned cracker plants in the region could result in additional health care costs of up to $80m annually for the local counties impacted as a result of increased respiratory ailments, lung cancer, asthma, and cardiovascular disease, as well as for the loss of work.  Plastic production is one of the few viable uses for ethane it —  some fracking executives say without it, their wells would not be financially viable.

Are Markets The Answer?

Many here at the climate meeting are touting market-based solutions to lead to better carbon emission outcomes.  But these market solutions often perpetuate environmental justice problems.  Consider that for this plant, Shell purchased pollution credits to offset its emissions, which is a way for a plant to exceed air pollution rules in one very localized area and such credits are easier to buy in areas that don’t meet federal air quality standards because they have lots of grandfathered pollution. It was even more controversial in this case because Shell could not find enough credits for its VOC emissions so, according to Yale Environment 360, it lobbied Pennsylvania environmental regulators to convert surplus nitrogen oxide credits into VOC credits, which will allow even more toxic pollution near the cracker plant when it comes online in 2021.  This means that the VOC emissions at the plant actually are allowed to be over a regional cap on such emissions.

Up Next

Emissions from Oil and Gas Operations Emit Much More Methane Than Previously Thought

Emissions from Oil and Gas Operations Emit Much More Methane Than Previously Thought

CNN and The Guardian reported late last week on a new study published in the journal Nature that concludes that methane emissions from fossil fuels are between 25% and 40% larger than past research had estimated, which means that oil and gas production is contributing roughly half of all greenhouse gas emissions — “far more” to climate change than previously estimated.

Why This Matters:  Methane is about 80 times more potent than carbon dioxide when looked at over a 20-year period.

Continue Reading 515 words
Fossil Fuels Cost the US Economy Billions According to Greenpeace Report

Fossil Fuels Cost the US Economy Billions According to Greenpeace Report

According to a new report from Greenpeace Southeast Asia and the Centre for Research on Energy and Clean Air, air pollution that’s generated by burning fossil fuels is responsible for approximately 4.5 million premature deaths worldwide every year. The report underscored that, Air pollution increases the incidence of chronic and acute illnesses and contributes to […]

Continue Reading 454 words
New Report Finds One-Third of Americans Breathe Dirty Air At Least 3 Months A Year

New Report Finds One-Third of Americans Breathe Dirty Air At Least 3 Months A Year

In 2018, nearly 110 million Americans lived in areas with air quality that was unhealthy for more than 100 days of the year, according to a new report published on Tuesday by Environment America Research & Policy Center, USPIRG Education Fund and Frontier Group.

Why This Matters:  Dirty air negatively impacts’ people’s health and even their life expectancy — as we have often reported here in Our Daily Planet, and air quality in the U.S. is not good enough, despite what the current administration may try to claim.

Continue Reading 490 words