New Report Throws Cold Water on Big Oil’s Plastic Plan

Graphic: Carbon Tracker    Source: EPA, CREA, WHO, UNEP, CT estimates, Breaking the Plastic Wave

By Julia Fine, ODP Contributing Writer

Last month, we reported on the plan of American companies to foist an increasing amount of plastic goods and garbage on African countries. These plastics represent the “thin reed upon which the [oil] industry is placing all its hopes.” But now, as David Roberts reported for Vox, a new report, “The Future’s Not In Plastics” by Carbon Tracker, “throws a big bucket of cold water on these hopes.” According to the report, despite the fact that oil and petrochemical companies are “betting their future growth on demand for plastics,” plastic demand is “likely to peak,” as they face increased regulation and public criticism.

Why This Matters: As Kingsmill Bond, energy strategist as Carbon Tracker, told The Guardian, “It is simply delusional for the plastics industry to imagine that it can double its carbon emissions at the same time as the rest of the world is trying to cut them to zero.”  And as the Carbon Tracker report predicted, the “mounting pressure to curtail the use of plastics” through regulation suggests that Big Oil will “lose its primary growth driver, making it more likely oil demand peaked as early as 2019.”

The Problems with Plastic

Plastics represent, according to Carbon Tracker, a “massive untaxed externality upon society.” This externality impacts global warming, ocean pollution, and public health. Now is the time to act on these issues; as Lidia Creech reported for Resource, a recent study demonstrated that without action, by 2040 the level of plastic pollution in our oceans could triple.

And, although some have argued that plastic is critical in fields like healthcare, as the report noted, “the amount of plastic used in PPE equipment is very low and not sufficient to outweigh falling plastic demand elsewhere.”

As Bond told The Guardian, “Remove the plastic pillar holding up the future of the oil industry, and the whole narrative of rising oil demand collapses.”  Unfortunately, the petrochemical industry is betting that the demand for virgin plastics use will increase by a quarter at a cost of at least $400 billion in the next 5 years, risking huge losses for investors.

Disrupting the Plastics Industry

Thankfully, there are a number of ways to “curtail demand for virgin plastics” that Carbon Tracker outlines in its reports. The report details the three main solutions for this disruption: first, reducing demand by implementing “better design and regulation,” substituting plastic goods with other products, and “massively increas[ing]” recycling.

While a recent Pew Charitable Trusts report noted there is “no single solution” on issues like ocean plastic pollution, if a number of steps are taken hand-in-hand, including both pre-consumer and post-consumer solutions, important strides can be made.

To Go Deeper: Read the report by the Pew Charitable Trusts on how we can “break the plastic wave,” as well as Carbon Tracker’s report on the “shaky” new plan of Big Oil to invest in plastics.

Up Next

Our Biggest Source of Clean Energy Is on the Line. We Have a Short Window to Save It.

Our Biggest Source of Clean Energy Is on the Line. We Have a Short Window to Save It.

By Josh Freed, Senior Vice President for the Climate and Energy Program, Third Way We’ve reached a critical juncture in America’s nuclear energy future. Put differently, we’re in make-or-break territory for reaching net-zero by 2050. That’s because nuclear still accounts for more than 50% of our carbon-free power, and we need all the clean energy […]

Continue Reading 667 words
How ‘Bout That D.E.R?

How ‘Bout That D.E.R?

It’s been quite a week for pipelines. Though the Colonial pipeline has resumed operations after being shut down by hackers earlier this week, its shuttering prompted gas shortages across the South and East Coast. The incident also increased calls by green groups and clean energy advocates to step up distributed energy resources. Wind and solar […]

Continue Reading 104 words
Enbridge Continues Operation Despite Whitmer’s Cease and Desist

Enbridge Continues Operation Despite Whitmer’s Cease and Desist

by Amy Lupica, ODP Staff Writer Canadian energy company Enbridge will continue to operate a pipeline transporting oil from the U.S. to Canada–despite Michigan Governor Gretchen Whitmer’s order to halt operations–– stating that the governor did not have the authority to cease the pipeline’s operations. The Line 5 pipeline transports millions of barrels of crude oil […]

Continue Reading 591 words

Want the planet in your inbox?

Subscribe to the email that top lawmakers, renowned scientists, and thousands of concerned citizens turn to each morning for the latest environmental news and analysis.