NOAA Delays Urgently Needed Right Whale Protections Again

A Right Whale being disentangled from fishing gear     Photo: David Abel, Twitter

The Boston Globe’s David Abel reported on Twitter last week that the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) is, according to court filings, delaying new protections for critically endangered North Atlantic Right Whales even after a court found the agency in violation of the Endangered Species Act for its failure to take action to protect them.  NOAA will not issue new rules until May 2021 — more than two years after a special team assembled by the agency voted to reduce the number of lobster gear lines in the Gulf of Maine by about 50 percent.  The Pew Charitable Trusts immediately petitioned for emergency action by NOAA to close certain areas in waters off New England to lobster and crab pots during times when right whales are likely to be present.

Why This Matters:  There are fewer than 400 North Atlantic Right Whales remaining. NOAA had promised the new rules by the end of last year, then by March, then July.  Now NOAA says proposed rules won’t come until “late summer or early fall,” depending on a review by White House.  The President was just in Maine and got an earful from lobster fishers, which begs the question of whether there has been political interference to keep the protections tied up in the agency.
Lobster and Crab Pots Entangle Whales
There are two issues facing Right Whales and causing their deaths — collisions with ships and entanglements in fishing gear with vertical lines that go from the surface to the seafloor, like traditional lobster and crab pots.  There are tens of thousands of pots (and millions of lines) in the waters off New England now, and this is also the season when North Atlantic Right Whales tend to congregate there.  According to Pew’s petition, “deaths and serious injuries of right whales continue to be well over what the population can biologically sustain, and more than four times the legally allowable limit. Entanglement in gear is the biggest threat to the species’ survival.”   They further allege that NOAA is out of compliance with the Endangered Species Act because their scientific opinion on whether and how the lobster and crab fisheries harm the whales is out of date, the agency has not given the fisheries a permit to “take whales” (i.e. to go ahead and fish despite whale deaths).  Indeed, NOAA Fisheries has done nothing to increase protections for the North Atlantic right whale since 2014, and since then their numbers have declined precipitously.
Pew argues that closing “some areas to fishing with the most harmful gear could immediately lower the risk to the whales while the federal government develops longer-term rules to reduce whale entanglements in fishing gear.”  The Court now must rule on whether the agency can further delay issuing rules to protect the Right Whale.  Lobster fishers might be willing to consider a new type of fishing gear that has no rope lines, but so far the agency has not required it and it is currently very expensive.
To Go Deeper:  There is a documentary film called “Entangled” about the Right Whale and NOAA’s failure to protect it — it will be released in a few weeks.  You can read about it here.  And read about potentially life-saving new lobster fishing gear technology here.

Up Next

Animal Activists Cautiously Celebrate as Federal Government Cracks Down on “Tiger Kings”

Animal Activists Cautiously Celebrate as Federal Government Cracks Down on “Tiger Kings”

When quarantine began, many of us were hooked on two things: Animal Crossing and Tiger King. Now, thanks to the hit Netflix docuseries, the federal government and the People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) are having an animal crossover all their own. PETA hopes to use a series of lawsuits against privately-owned tiger and “exotic” animal “zoos” to set a precedent under the Endangered Species Act. 

Why This Matters: There is currently no federal law preventing the ownership of wildlife, endangered or otherwise.

Continue Reading 679 words
Sea Cucumber is The Latest Victim of Endangered Animal Trade

Sea Cucumber is The Latest Victim of Endangered Animal Trade

by Amy Lupica, ODP Staff Writer The latest victim of the endangered animal trade is the sea cucumber. These creatures, often the butt of jokes due to their suggestive shape and silly name, have been growing in value for over a decade, and have now been aggressively overfished. Sea cucumbers play a crucial role in their ecosystems and the overall health of […]

Continue Reading 590 words
Climate Migration is Happening Underwater, Too

Climate Migration is Happening Underwater, Too

by Ashira Morris, ODP Staff Writer The ocean is warming, and marine life is moving to survive. Tropical waters around the equator were the richest with species, but it’s now too hot for some of them to survive, according to a new study. Looking at 48,661 marine species, the study found marine life drops off […]

Continue Reading 396 words

Want the planet in your inbox?

Subscribe to the email that top lawmakers, renowned scientists, and thousands of concerned citizens turn to each morning for the latest environmental news and analysis.