Please invest in Our Daily Planet today, by making a one time or monthly contribution.
We do not charge our readers a subscription fee for our content. We want to continue to grow our readership, particularly among millennials and public servants. Voluntary contributions from readers will help us employ interns and freelance journalists, expand our content, and reach a larger audience.
John Muir in 1906. Photo by Francis M. Fritz (Creative Commons)
John Muir is perhaps America’s most famous naturalist and conservationist as well as the founder of the Sierra Club. His writings and teachings convinced the U.S. government to protect Yosemite, Sequoia, Grand Canyon and Mt. Rainier as national parks and have also inspired generations of conservationists to follow in his footsteps. Yet at a time when many cities and institutions are assessing their historical ties to white supremacy, the Sierra Club is having a reckoning with its founder and his problematic beliefs. As Sierra Club’s executive director Michael Brune wrote in a blog post: “It’s time to take down some of our own monuments, starting with some truth-telling about the Sierra Club’s early history.”
as these actions pertain to Muir specifically, Brune went on to say that,
“As the most iconic figure in Sierra Club history, Muir’s words and actions carry an especially heavy weight. They continue to hurt and alienate Indigenous people and people of color who come into contact with the Sierra Club.”
Why This Matters: This announcement is not the “cancelation” of a historical figure, it’s a nuanced statement that comes clean about the fact that conservation of the outdoors in the United States cannot be divorced from human affairs–to do so only perpetuates white supremacy. Green groups and the conservation movement have continually struggled with diversity and inclusion and part of righting that wrong comes with acknowledging history and implementing tangible steps to reframe how conservation functions and who it serves.
What Are We Protecting?: A salient point that Brune makes in his post is that for white people, the outdoor places they love are often stolen lands. Brune writes,
Such willful ignorance is what allows some people to shut their eyes to the reality that the wild places we love are also the ancestral homelands of Native peoples, forced off their lands in the decades or centuries before they became national parks. It allows them to overlook, too, the fact that only people insulated from systemic racism and brutality can afford to focus solely on preserving wilderness.
A Complicated Past: John Muir, Madison Grant, Henry Fairfield Osborn, and President Theodore Roosevelt are remembered for their legacy of conservation in the early 20th century yet as many men of their time who were of a certain social class, they held problematic views regarding white supremacy and agencies. As the New Yorker wrote in a piece from 2015, “for these conservationists, who prized the expert governance of resources, it was an unsettlingly short step from managing forests to managing the human gene pool.”
Go Deeper: The reckoning our nation (as well as many other nations) is having around historical racism is moving swiftly and it can be difficult to take in the nuance. “Should we judge historical figures by today’s moral standards?” is a question that keeps appearing recently and everyone seems to have a different view. The BBC recently asked an array of historians about how they grapple with this question, it’s worth a read to help shape your own framework for understanding history.
Moving Forward:As CNN reported Sierra Club’s reforms will try to fix some of the lasting issues in the club’s history including redesigning their leadership structure so that “Black, Indigenous, and other leaders of color at the Sierra Club make up the majority of the team making top-level organizational decisions.”
Five million dollars of its budget will also be shifted to make investments in the organization’s staff of color and on environmental and racial justice work.
“I know that the steps I’ve outlined above are only the beginnings of what will be a years-long process to reckon with our history, regain trust from the communities we have harmed, and create a diverse and equitable Sierra Club for the 21st century,” Michael Brune concluded.
With air travel more difficult and risky this year, many families are taking vacations the old-fashioned way — by going on a road trip. And we hear that renting a recreational vehicle or RV is quite popular. It is a great way to “see the country,” and maybe visit some National Parks, while maintaining coronavirus […]
Derek Green is an at-large member of the Philadelphia City Council. As a member of City Council, Councilmember Green chairs the Committee on Finance and Disabilities and serves as the Vice Chair of the Committees on Aging and Law and Government. Additionally, he serves as the Chair of the Philadelphia Gas Commission, in addition to […]
This week our hero is eight-year-old Ali Hirsch, who won’t vote for another ten years but wants to make a difference. She has donated all her saved allowance and birthday money to an organization fighting to make sure every American can vote in November, with the help of her parents of course. She chose The […]
Our Daily Planet is your daily dose of the stories shaping our world and the ways that you can take action. From the climate crisis to the protection of biodiversity, if these issues matter to you then please subscribe & stay informed!
Your privacy is Important! We promise never to use your email address to send you spam or advertisements.