Trump Rolls Back Endangered Species Protections, Despite Widespread Public Support

Image: Stephen Meyers

Enacted with bipartisan support in 1973, the Endangered Species Act (ESA) is the United States’ most effective species conservation law but the Trump Administration has made the act a target in their efforts to roll back environmental protections. As Vox reported, yesterday, “the US Fish and Wildlife Service and the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration announced they were pushing through changes to the Endangered Species Act that will, in effect, weaken protections for species, and possibly give industry more leeway to develop areas where threatened animals live.” While a draft proposal of these rule changes was announced last summer, The New York Times added that the new rules are expected to appear in the Federal Register this week and will go into effect 30 days after that.

The Specifics: As the New York Times explained, the changes to the ESA made by the Trump administration “will make it harder to consider the effects of climate change on wildlife when deciding whether a given species warrants protection. They would most likely shrink critical habitats and, for the first time, would allow economic assessments to be conducted when making determinations.” That’s right, it will have to make financial sense to protect endangered species.

What’s at Stake: As IFAW’s Beth Allgood explained in her recent Bright Ideas op-ed,

The effectiveness of the Endangered Species Act is indisputable. This bedrock legislation has prevented more than 99 percent of listed species from going extinct, our own iconic bald eagle among them. The Act provides a framework through which to strengthen citizen stewardship for wildlife, while serving as a model for species conservation across the globe. Put simply, the protections afforded to imperiled species under this legislation are the key driver behind the U.S. achieving unsurpassed success in terms of species recovery versus any other nation in the world.

ESA, A Striking Success: As the World Wildlife Fund wrote, “99% of species protected by the list have avoided extinction. Grizzly bears, humpback whales, and bald eagles are just some of the 46 species now listed as recovered under the ESA.” It’s because of these successes that there is such widespread public support for the ESA.

Why This Matters:  While Interior Secretary David Bernhardt says the revisions will help conservation efforts and increase transparency around the law, this revision may help business but it’s bad for animals. Here’s Monica’s take, “The changes by the Trump administration to the ESA will provide less protection for threatened species and make delisting them easier. Plus putting a value on species is always controversial because saving animals and plants is never economically valued fairly. The truth is the act is already implemented weakly so the real-life impacts are not going to be huge because we are going from bad to worse. With the specter of climate change and loss of habitat already making mass extinction a huge concern, this sends all the wrong signals.”

Up Next

North Atlantic Right Whale and Many Species of Lemurs Now Critically Endangered

North Atlantic Right Whale and Many Species of Lemurs Now Critically Endangered

The International Union for the Conservation of Nature (IUCN), which is the global authority when it comes to whether a species is at risk of extinction, yesterday added the North Atlantic Right Whale of the eastern U.S. to its list of Critically Endangered species (elevated from Endangered) that are on the brink of extinction.  The IUCN also “upgraded” 13 different species of lemurs to the Critically Endangered list along with 20 other lemur species at risk of imminent extinction.

Why This Matters:  These species are on the verge of going extinct not because of anything they did, but rather because of us humans.

Continue Reading 561 words

One Turtle Thing: Tsunami Finds A Home In St. Louis

We just love a tsunami with a happy ending!  The Georgia Sea Turtle Center on St. Simons Island had been rehabilitating Tsunami, an endangered green sea turtle that was hit by a boat in 2017, for years with the hope of setting her free in the ocean.  But her injuries were too severe to survive […]

Continue Reading 174 words
Here’s How the US Government Can Help Prevent the Next Pandemic

Here’s How the US Government Can Help Prevent the Next Pandemic

By Will Gartshore, Director of Government Affairs and Advocacy, World Wildlife Fund (WWF) “Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.” It’s an old aphorism that still rings painfully true today. Long before Covid-19, the three deadliest pandemics in human history—the bubonic plague, Spanish influenza and HIV/AIDS—claimed more lives than all the […]

Continue Reading 963 words