Venice Floods Again — What to Do When You Can’t Move to Higher Ground?

Workers clean up after high waters flooded the interior of St. Mark’s Basilica.      Photo: Luca Bruno, AP

The historic city of Venice (a UNESCO world heritage site) flooded for the third time in a week, with Piazza St. Mark closed to tourists again on Sunday, and in Pisa and Florence torrential rains threaten to flood there too as the President of the region warned of a “flood wave” on the Arno that threads through both cities.  Venice houses hundreds of priceless artworks by the Italian Renaissance masters and is full of historic sights, such as St. Mark’s Cathedral that dates back one thousand years, historic basilicas, and a series of famous canals.

Why This Matters:  Venice is a world treasure — it’s a city that floods with millions of tourists each year and is home to about 50,000 residents who depend on them. Its future is very much in doubt given the repeated and devastating floods — its residents are beginning to believe they are fighting a losing battle.  While some of the priceless art can be saved by moving it to higher ground, the buildings and the treasures that are part of their walls, as well as the romantic canals and squares like St. Mark’s, cannot simply be moved to higher ground.  Once submerged they are gone for good.  This tragedy may seem half a world away, but it is a harbinger of things to come — the same thing could soon happen in lower New Orleans, Manhattan and Miami Beach.

Flooding Already Causing the City To Shrink

According to The Washington Post, the city has been losing residents for years, due to a trio of inundation — floods, high prices, and overcrowding due to tourists.  Experts say climate change is taking its toll by making the city less accessible for everyone “as the very attractions tourists and locals enjoy dissolve.”  The damage to the relics will be hard to restore.

  • Throughout Venice, volunteers were at work trying to salvage what they could, like the ones who were carefully leafing centuries-old sheet music that had been soaked by floodwater — the Italian Society of Authors and Editors said Venice’s bookstores and libraries were “gravely damaged,” according to the AP.

It is not just a question of whether restoration is possible, it is also the safety of the structures themselves even after they dry out.

“Venice is used to being constantly surrounded by water, but this is really something else,” Toto Bergamo Rossi, director of Venetian Heritage, told CNN. “The main issue is saltwater. When salt permeates the materials of these buildings — be them marble, tiling, plaster or wood — it crystallizes and ascends vertically once the weather gets drier, from the ground to the first floor and so on. It’s almost like a cancer for these structures, all the more so when they are so old. The entire wall system can be affected.”

Up Next

EU To Pass Europe-Wide Climate Law, But Will Miss Current Emission Reduction Goals

EU To Pass Europe-Wide Climate Law, But Will Miss Current Emission Reduction Goals

In a report published on Wednesday, the European Environment Agency said that Europe’s progress towards cutting greenhouse-gas emissions and boosting the share of renewables in the energy mix is not happening quickly enough and as a result, the EU will miss its goals.  Moreover, the EU can expect to confront heat waves that are more severe than recent record-breaking events every two years from 2050 on, The Telegraph reported.

Why This Matters:  The EU considers itself a climate leader globally and so missing these targets is a big deal.

Continue Reading 483 words
At UN Climate Meeting, WMO Sounds Alarm and Urges More Climate Services

At UN Climate Meeting, WMO Sounds Alarm and Urges More Climate Services

The World Meteorological Organization (WMO) issued a report saying that 2019 “concludes a decade of exceptional global heat, retreating ice and record sea levels driven by greenhouse gases from human activities.”

Why This Matters:  Piling on to the UN’s Gap report from last week, the WMO’s clear-eyed diagnosis is that the planet is warming much more rapidly than previously thought, and the prognosis is that global average temps will be 3 times higher than the Paris Agreement levels if we remain on the current trajectory of warming. What a chilling forecast.

Continue Reading 566 words
Annual UN Climate Meeting Opens With Strong Admonition by the Secretary General

Annual UN Climate Meeting Opens With Strong Admonition by the Secretary General

After another UN Environment Program report last week made clear that the gap between climate action and necessary progress continues to widen, the Secretary-General excoriated the assembled 190 governments’ climate negotiators on Sunday, saying that so far the world’s efforts to stop climate change have been “utterly inadequate” and warned that global warming could soon pass the “point of no return.” 

Why This Matters:  Unfortunately, the three largest emitting countries — the United States, China, and India — have sent only lower-level officials to represent their governments at the UN meeting.

Continue Reading 502 words