Please invest in Our Daily Planet today, by making a one time or monthly contribution.
We do not charge our readers a subscription fee for our content. We want to continue to grow our readership, particularly among millennials and public servants. Voluntary contributions from readers will help us employ interns and freelance journalists, expand our content, and reach a larger audience.
If you make a contribution of $150 or more, you will become an official “Friend of the Planet” and receive a Friend of the Planet T-shirt or water bottle. You can also submit opinion essays to us for our consideration for posting on our new “Bright Ideas” op-ed page.
San Joaquin Kit Fox – one of the impacted endangered species Photo: Mark A. Chappell
According to The New York Times, David Bernhardt, who has been nominated to be the Secretary of Interior, personally intervened to squash the planned public release in 2017 of a thorough report that was years in the making on the negative impacts of three major pesticides on endangered species. Based on documents obtained by the Center for Biological Diversity and The New York Times, it appears that the scientists conducting the review were about to conclude that the use of these pesticides at approved levels could cause the extinction of 1,200 species of plants and animals. This conclusion would possibly have led to tighter restrictions on the use of these dangerous pesticides, a result their manufacturers were trying hard to avoid, but it would not have led to a total ban of them.
The Act requires the Interior Department’s biologists to determine the impact of the use of pesticides that are approved by EPA — under what is known as a “Section 7” consultation. If they find that the use of the pesticide at its permissible levels will jeopardize the continued existence of certain endangered species, then EPA would discuss with Interior what to do to ensure that such species survive.
The most important chemicals involved in the review are chlorpyrifos, which is used on dozens of fruits and vegetables and made by Dow AgroChemical, and malathion, which made by FMC Corporation and is used against mosquitoes as well as chewing and sucking insects that attack a range of crops including tomatoes, strawberries and walnuts. EPA is currently under a court order to ban the use of chlorpyrifos because of the harm its use on food products allegedly causes to humans, but the case is on appeal.
The lead career employee at the Interior Department who oversaw the study said he was not troubled by the decision by the leadership there “’It was an entirely appropriate role,” he said in an interview with The Times, as two of the agency’s public affairs officials listened in. “There was no arm-twisting of any kind.’”
Why This Matters:This kind of politicization of science is why Senator Schatz and Congressman Tanko’s bill on sound science in the government is so important. It is understandable that agency’s political appointees would meet with industry representatives about an important issue — in my (Monica) time, we met with lots of representatives of stakeholders when a decision was pending at my agency. What is NOT appropriate is changing the decision that had been based on the best judgment of agency scientists and holding secret meetings with the representatives of only one side of an issue. In my time in government, we set up formal and informal meeting at appropriate times during a decision process to give all sides a chance to be heard, and we did it on the record so the public would know. Acting Secretary Bernhardt’s confirmation hearing is Thursday – he should explain why he shelved the report and make the prior version public.
Congressional Democrats didn’t get the green strings attached for the airline industry bailout this week, but we can always hope for the next round of stimulus funding. At least the bill’s not bailing out the oil industry? Cartoon by Alex Bowman (check out more of her art here)
The Senate was unable to agree on a bipartisan stimulus bill yesterday — negotiations apparently stalled because, among other things, the Democrats demanded that bailouts for airlines be conditioned on their lowering their emissions and that tax credits for wind and solar projects be extended.
Why This Matters: After dragging his feet on immediate economic relief and adjourning the Senate over the weekend ten days ago, now Senator McConnell seems in a big rush to give billions to corporations while leaving workers and the environment out of the deal.