Trump Administration Orders Manipulation of Climate Science

The New York Times reported yesterday that in addition to significantly weakening Obama Administration policies and rules that would have cut U.S. greenhouse gas emissions, now the Trump Administration is working to “recalculate” the risks posed by climate change by ordering scientists to ignore long term impacts beyond 2040 and to omit analysis of the worst-case scenarios in the next national climate assessment report.

Why This Matters:  Here we go again.  The George W. Bush Administration also tried to squelch the science around climate change — their tactic was to have politicians redraft the scientific conclusions and to put greater emphasis on analysis of uncertainties surrounding climate science at the time. They were unable to succeed because government scientists were able to point to their results and vouch for them — they could object on the merits. The Trump Administration’s plan is more dangerous because by not performing these analyses the ability of outsiders and the government’s own scientists to critique the government’s actions will be diminished.  We won’t know what we don’t know.  And what we don’t know can and will hurt us.  

What This Will Mean For Climate Science:  This will lead to incomplete data and analysis on which to base government decisions and plans.

  • Scientists claim that this will warp the picture of the business as usual scenario because the worst impacts of climate change do not begin until after 2050.
  • Until now, scientists have used computer models to analyze several different scenarios through the end of the century including as much as an 8-degree temperature rise.
  • “Nobody in the world does climate science like that,” said Michael Oppenheimer, a professor of geosciences and international affairs at Princeton. “It would be like designing cars without seatbelts or airbags.”

The Climate Change Strippers:  The list of Trump political appointees who have stripped climate change information from official documents is growing.

  • The Times reported that the “White House-appointed director of the United States Geological Survey, James Reilly, a former astronaut and petroleum geologist, has ordered that scientific assessments produced by that office use only computer-generated climate models that project the impact of climate change through 2040 rather than through the end of the century.”
  • In addition to Secretary of State Pompeo, another prominent climate denier is National Security Advisor John Bolton who officials say instructed them to strip references to global warming from speeches and other formal statements.

Some Agencies Are Resisting:  Not all government science agencies are planning such changes. A spokesman for the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, asked if its scientists would limit the use of climate models, wrote in an email, “No changes are being considered at this time.”

Up Next

Coastal Red States Apply For Millions in Adaptation Funding With No Mention of Climate Change

Coastal Red States Apply For Millions in Adaptation Funding With No Mention of Climate Change

Billions of dollars of disaster preparedness funding are up for grabs from the Trump Administration, but to improve their odds of getting some of it, states are going out of their way NOT to mention climate change, according to The New York Times.

Why This Matters:  Climate denials — explicit or implicit — don’t make its impacts or the need to adapt any less real.

Continue Reading 520 words
UN Rules on New Protections for Climate Refugees

UN Rules on New Protections for Climate Refugees

Human rights advocates are cheering a landmark decision by the UN Human Rights Committee (HRC) mandating that governments must take into account the human rights violations caused by the climate crisis when considering the deportation of asylum seekers. In the decision, the UNHRC outlined that countries could violate people’s international rights if they force them […]

Continue Reading 403 words
World Economic Forum’s Risk Report Names Major Climate Threats

World Economic Forum’s Risk Report Names Major Climate Threats

This year the World Economic Forum’s annual risks report focuses on climate change in a major way because its effects are entirely undeniable. 

Continue Reading 419 words